Garage doors are essential components of any home’s exterior, offering functionality and aesthetic appeal. Among the most popular styles are Coachman and Carriage House garage doors. Though they may appear similar at first glance, both styles differ in design elements, materials, and customization options. Choosing between these two types can influence the overall look and feel of your home, as well as its curb appeal and property value. In this blog post, Jonathan’s Garage Door will explore the key differences between Coachman and Carriage House garage doors to help you make an informed decision when selecting the right door for your home.
1: Aesthetic Differences
One of the primary distinctions between Coachman and Carriage House garage doors lies in their aesthetics. Coachman garage doors are known for their traditional, sophisticated look that mimics the classic carriage house style but with a more modern twist. They often incorporate clean lines, understated decorative hardware, and window designs that align with contemporary tastes. On the other hand, Carriage House garage doors emphasize old-world charm, featuring bold, rustic details like crossbuck panels, decorative iron handles, and hinge straps. Homeowners seeking a more vintage, farmhouse-inspired design often gravitate towards Carriage House garage doors, while Coachman doors offer a blend of tradition and modernity.
2: Materials Used
When it comes to materials, Coachman and Carriage House garage doors present different options that impact durability, maintenance, and insulation. Coachman doors are commonly constructed from insulated steel with a faux wood overlay, combining the strength of steel with the classic look of wood. This provides homeowners with the beauty of wood without the associated maintenance issues. In contrast, Carriage House garage doors can be made from various materials, including natural wood, steel, and composite. Wood doors offer authentic charm but require regular upkeep, while steel and composite options provide more durability and lower maintenance. The choice of materials affects both performance and appearance over time.
3: Insulation and Energy Efficiency
Energy efficiency is a crucial factor for homeowners, and Coachman and Carriage House garage doors offer different levels of insulation. Coachman garage doors typically come with high-performance insulation options, featuring polystyrene or polyurethane insulation, which can significantly reduce energy costs by maintaining a more stable indoor temperature. These doors are ideal for garages that are attached to homes or used as extended living spaces. Carriage House doors, depending on the material, can also offer insulated options, particularly when made from steel or composite materials. However, if you opt for natural wood, insulation may be less effective, making Coachman doors a better choice for energy-conscious homeowners.

4: Durability and Maintenance Requirements
Durability is another key difference between Coachman and Carriage House garage doors, especially when considering long-term maintenance. Coachman doors, constructed primarily from steel with a wood overlay, are highly durable and resistant to warping, cracking, or splitting, which are common issues with natural wood. They require minimal maintenance, only occasional cleaning and lubrication of moving parts. Carriage House doors, particularly those made from wood, demand more attention, including regular staining or painting to protect the material from the elements. Steel or composite Carriage House doors offer more durability but may still require more upkeep compared to the relatively low-maintenance Coachman doors, making them ideal for homeowners with busy lifestyles.
5: Noise Reduction and Soundproofing
Noise reduction is an important consideration, especially if your garage is adjacent to living spaces. Coachman garage doors, with their steel construction and insulation layers, offer excellent noise reduction properties. The combination of insulated panels and sturdy materials dampens vibrations, making them a quieter option for daily use. Carriage House garage doors, depending on the materials used, can vary in soundproofing capabilities. Wooden Carriage House doors may produce more noise due to the natural material’s ability to resonate sounds. Steel or composite versions of Carriage House doors, particularly those with insulation, provide better noise control. For quieter operation, Coachman doors tend to have the upper hand.
6: Weather Resistance and Climate Suitability
Weather resistance is crucial when selecting a garage door, especially in areas with harsh climates. Coachman garage doors, with their steel core and weather-resistant finishes, are designed to withstand extreme weather conditions, including high winds, rain, and snow. The insulated layers in Coachman doors also help regulate indoor temperatures and reduce drafts. Carriage House garage doors, especially those made of wood, may be more susceptible to weather-related damage, such as warping or rotting, without proper maintenance. Steel or composite Carriage House doors, however, provide better protection. In regions with challenging weather, Coachman garage doors typically offer superior climate resilience and require less upkeep.
7: Security Features
Security is another vital factor to consider when choosing between Coachman and Carriage House garage doors. Coachman doors often come equipped with advanced locking mechanisms and sturdy steel construction, making them highly secure against break-ins. The materials used in Coachman doors provide a strong defense, and modern models may include smart technology for remote access and monitoring. Carriage House garage doors, especially wood models, may not be as inherently secure, though reinforced steel options offer improved safety. For homeowners prioritizing security, Coachman doors typically provide stronger construction and better integration with smart home security systems, offering peace of mind for you and your family.
8: Customization Options
When it comes to customization, both Coachman and Carriage House garage doors offer a wide range of options to fit various home styles. Coachman doors provide a blend of modern and traditional customization choices, allowing homeowners to select from an array of colors, finishes, window inserts, and decorative hardware. They often feature faux wood overlays, which can be stained or painted to match your home’s exterior. Carriage House doors, on the other hand, offer more vintage-inspired customization options, particularly when made from wood. Homeowners can choose from various panel designs, decorative hinges, and handles to enhance the rustic charm of their doors. The customization potential for both styles ensures a personalized touch.

9: Cost Differences
The cost of garage doors is a significant factor for homeowners when deciding between Coachman and Carriage House styles. Generally, Coachman garage doors are more affordable, especially when made from steel or composite materials. Their cost-effective insulation options and low maintenance needs make them an excellent investment for budget-conscious homeowners. Carriage House garage doors, particularly those crafted from natural wood, tend to be more expensive. This higher price point reflects both the material’s authenticity and the craftsmanship required. Additionally, wood doors typically require more upkeep, which can increase long-term costs. For those seeking a balance of elegance and affordability, Coachman garage doors may offer better value.
10: Installation and Professional Expertise
Proper installation is crucial to the performance and longevity of both Coachman and Carriage House garage doors. Coachman doors, due to their steel construction, tend to be lighter and easier to install, requiring less complex support systems. This can result in a faster and more cost-effective installation process. Carriage House garage doors, particularly those made from wood, are often heavier and may require specialized installation to ensure they operate smoothly and safely. Hiring a professional installer with experience in handling both types of doors is essential to avoid potential issues down the line, ensuring that your investment in either door style is well-protected and functions efficiently.
11: Curb Appeal and Home Value Impact
The visual impact of garage doors on a home’s curb appeal is undeniable, and both Coachman and Carriage House doors can significantly enhance the appearance and value of your property. Coachman doors, with their sleek and modern take on traditional design, can complement a wide range of architectural styles, from contemporary homes to classic suburban designs. Their balanced blend of old and new makes them versatile and attractive to potential buyers. Carriage House garage doors, with their bold and rustic appeal, are ideal for homes with a vintage or farmhouse aesthetic. Installing either style can boost your home’s market value, but the choice depends on your home’s design.
12: How to Choose Between Coachman and Carriage House Garage Doors
Choosing between Coachman and Carriage House garage doors ultimately depends on your aesthetic preferences, budget, and practical needs. If you prefer a modernized version of traditional carriage-style doors with minimal maintenance, Coachman garage doors may be the ideal choice. They offer durability, energy efficiency, and cost-effective customization options. However, if you are drawn to a more rustic, vintage charm and are willing to invest in natural wood or a high-quality replica, Carriage House garage doors could be the right fit. Consider factors such as insulation, long-term maintenance, and the overall architectural style of your home before making a final decision.
Conclusion
In conclusion, Coachman and Carriage House garage doors each offer unique advantages in terms of style, materials, and functionality. Coachman doors provide a modern twist on the classic carriage house look, offering durability, low maintenance, and energy efficiency. Carriage House doors, on the other hand, emphasize rustic charm and vintage appeal but may require more upkeep, especially if made from wood. Understanding the key differences between these two styles can help you select the perfect garage door that complements your home’s exterior while meeting your practical needs. Whether you prioritize cost, aesthetics, or energy efficiency, both options can enhance the beauty and value of your home.
FAQs
1. What are the main differences between Coachman and Carriage House garage doors?
Coachman garage doors offer a modern take on traditional carriage-style doors, typically made from steel with a faux wood overlay. Carriage House doors emphasize a rustic, vintage look with bold design elements and are often made from natural wood or steel.
2. Are Coachman garage doors more energy-efficient than Carriage House garage doors?
Yes, Coachman garage doors generally provide better insulation options, which can improve energy efficiency, particularly if your garage is attached to your home. Carriage House doors, especially those made from wood, may not offer the same level of insulation.
3. Which garage door style is more affordable, Coachman or Carriage House?
Coachman garage doors tend to be more affordable, especially when made from steel or composite materials. Carriage House doors, particularly those crafted from natural wood, are usually more expensive due to material and craftsmanship costs.
4. Which garage door style requires less maintenance?
Coachman garage doors require less maintenance because they are made from durable, low-maintenance materials like steel with a faux wood overlay. Carriage House garage doors, especially those made from wood, demand more regular upkeep, including staining or painting.
5. Can I customize both Coachman and Carriage House garage doors?
Yes, both styles offer extensive customization options. Coachman doors offer modern and traditional finishes, while Carriage House doors emphasize vintage-inspired designs, particularly for homeowners seeking a rustic look.